I ignored all the “beach” ones except Baby Beach. Wow, there is plenty to see and do:

• Philip's Animal Garden, Noord
• Baby Beach, San Nicolas
• Arikok National Park, Santa Cruz
• Natural Pool
• National Archaeological Museum Aruba
• Ayo and Casibari Rock Formations
• Seroe Colorado (geologic formations)
• Guadirikiri Caves (awesome)
• Wilhelmina Park, Oranjestad
• Natural Bridge
• Museo Arubano, Oranjestad (Aruba History Museum)
• Bushiri Karting Speedway, Oranjestad (SPEEDWAY!?!) hehe
• Stonehenge of Aruba
• De Man Shell Collection, Oranjestad

• Tour of lighthouse and north side of island.
• Snorkeling at Baby Beach in lagoon on southeastern tip of island. Bring bread to feed the fish. We rented a car to get there.
• 1/2 day sport fishing on charter boat. Caught a wahoo and lost a marlin. Water was very rough even though it was calm at the beach.
• Semi-submersible submarine tour of shipwrecks.

• She mentioned a pirate ship that sails around the bay and they feed you dinner.
  • Probably this: Jolly Pirates Cruises
• She also mentioned a bus that drives around the island where you can drink on the bus, but that's more of an adult only experience I should think
  • Here is the Kukoo Kunuku Bus

Just looking at Trip Advisor Restaurants, these jumped out at me: (it looks like we have lots of choices)

• Costa Riba, San Nicolas
• Barefoot Restaurant
• Hollywood Smokehouse
• Scott's Brats

You know what.. never mind… there are so many, all of these sound awesome … we will just look while down there and head to whatever we're in the mood for or eat at home.